Judge Says UDF Lawsuit Against Kyle Bass and Hayman Capital Will Proceed
June 13, 2018 | James Sprow | BlueVault
In an article posted on Blue Vault’s website on December 19, 2017, entitled “How An Attack on a Nontraded REIT Sponsor Made a Hedge Fund Manager $60 Million,” we referred readers to a lawsuit filed by United Development Funding LP (“UDF”) and its related companies accusing hedge fund manager J. Kyle Bass and his closely held company Hayman Capital Management, L.P., of perpetrating a “short-and-distort” scheme by spreading false and damaging information about UDF in order to drive down the company’s stock price and profit by covering their short positions by buying shorted shares at much lower prices.
On June 12, after six months of litigation between United Development Funding and defendants J. Kyle Bass (“Bass”) and Hayman Capital (“Hayman”), a Dallas County Court (the “Court”) denied the Defendants’ bid to dismiss UDF’s lawsuit under the Texas Citizen’s Participation Act (the “TCPA”).
UDF filed the lawsuit last November claiming Bass and Hayman made false statements that disparaged UDF’s business and interfered with its contracts and business relations, and that those statements were made with malice and caused extensive damage to UDF’s business. The Defendants then filed a motion under the TCPA, known as an anti-SLAPP motion, and argued that the Defendants were exercising rights of free speech in publishing negative material concerning UDF’s business—first anonymously and then on a proprietary website—and that the speech was made without actual malice. In March, the Court authorized limited discovery, including the production of some documentary evidence. After an extended evidentiary hearing, the Court ruled in favor of UDF, and has allowed the lawsuit to proceed to trial.
“We are very pleased with the Court’s ruling and the Court’s allowance of limited discovery prior to the ruling,” said UDF’s Hollis Greenlaw. “The limited discovery granted by the Court allowed us to see this coordinated plan documented in the emails and texts of Bass and Hayman. We intend to pursue the lawsuit to trial as expeditiously as possible, and we look forward to our day in court.”
Ellen Cirangle, counsel for UDF, stated, “In all the cases that I have done, I have never seen such extensive dissemination of negative information about a company, including through anonymous postings.”
As part of UDF’s opposition to Defendants’ motion, UDF submitted eleven affidavits that included testimony in support from developers, a banker, brokers, investors, executives and a forensic accounting expert who was formerly Ernst & Young’s fraud investigations practice leader in the Americas.
Today’s Court ruling removes the stay of discovery that was automatically imposed by Defendants’ filing of the TCPA motion and enables UDF to move beyond the initial, limited discovery into full discovery on the merits of the case. However, Defendants have the ability to further delay discovery by appealing the Court’s ruling, if they are unwilling to proceed with the trial court case at this time. No assurances can be given that UDF will receive any damages as a result of the lawsuit, nor can any assurances be given regarding a timeframe for a resolution of the lawsuit.
Public documents filed with the court, including discovery and UDF’s filings, can be found at www.udfonline.com/litigation. The case is styled United Development Funding, L.P. et al. v. J. Kyle Bass et al., Case No. CC-17-06253-C in Dallas County Court at Law No. 3. Counsel for UDF are Ellen Cirangle, Jonathan Sommer and Kyle Withers of Lubin Olson & Niewiadomski LLP in San Francisco, California, and Joe Cox and Andrea Broyles at Bracewell LLP in Dallas.
About United Development Funding IV
United Development Funding IV is a public Maryland real estate investment trust. UDF IV was formed primarily to generate current interest income by investing in secured loans and producing profits from investments in residential real estate. Additional information about UDF IV can be found on its website at www.udfiv.com. UDF IV may disseminate important information regarding its operations, including financial information, through social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook and LinkedIn.
Sources: Blue Vault https://bv.flavorexp.net/how-an-attack-on-a-nontraded-reit-sponsor-made-a-hedge-fund-manager-60-million; UDF Press Release 6/12/2018
The Blue Vault Summit could not have been more perfectly timed. This gathering of the Broker Dealer and Sponsor communities provided insightful and open discussion from several vantage points. These conversations are paramount, especially in a time of significant regulatory change.